Title: “In Defense of Arthur Smith: Why the Falcons Should Extend His Contract”
The article strongly advocates for the Atlanta Falcons to give Arthur Smith another year as head coach, drawing a clear distinction from past decisions, particularly Dan Quinn’s extension in 2020. It argues that the Falcons made a mistake by giving Quinn an additional year, but the situation with Smith is different.
While acknowledging the disappointments of the 2023 season, the article emphasizes the need to grant Smith more time to address the team’s challenges. It highlights the failures, including offensive regression and the decision to start Desmond Ridder, but argues against a hasty decision, pointing out the potential for improvement with continued coaching.
The piece acknowledges the frustrations of the current season, expressing concerns about the offense’s lack of progress and inconsistent performance. Despite this, it suggests that Smith’s coaching scheme has demonstrated success, especially when there’s consistent quarterback play and a productive run game. The call is for patience in finding the right balance between creativity and situational common sense.
The article credits Smith for his ability to hire quality assistants,
particularly praising the impact of defensive coordinator Ryan Nielsen. It draws a parallel with Quinn’s failure to replace key personnel, highlighting Smith’s success in building a strong supporting staff, particularly on the defensive side.
The positive culture within the locker room under Smith’s leadership is emphasized, drawing parallels with Quinn’s tenure. The article argues that maintaining this cohesive atmosphere should be a factor in the decision-making process, even if it’s not the sole reason to retain Smith.
NFL insider Albert Breer’s belief in Smith’s potential success is mentioned as a supporting argument for keeping Smith. The article suggests that patience with Smith could lead to sustained success, especially when a franchise quarterback is secured for the future.
Comparing Smith’s tenure with Quinn’s downward spiral, the article contends that the current situation feels different, and Sunday’s game provides a glimpse of a better future. It argues that the team can perform well under Smith’s leadership when everything aligns correctly, making a case for continuity.
Despite acknowledging that keeping Smith might not be universally popular, the article suggests it is the right call. It warns against a hasty coaching change that could result in roster retooling and additional transition time. The final recommendation is for team owner Arthur Blank to give Smith another year to figure things out, particularly with the potential of securing the right quarterback.
Leave a Reply